Policy Issues
The Computing Research Association has been involved in shaping federal public policy of relevance to computing research for more than fifteen years, and weighs in on multiple issues that can affect the computing researching community. The Issues pages below provide links to information on research, science, and technology policy, with emphasis on issues of interest to computing research. While not comprehensive, below are a number of issues that the Association has worked on over the past few years. As new issues arise, which require CRA’s input, they will be added. To find out specifics on what CRA has done, please read through our Policy Blog.
Information Technology R&D
Advances in information technology (IT) are changing our lives, driving our economy, and transforming the conduct of science. America is the world leader in IT innovation because of a complex interplay of universities, industry, and the federal government. Essentially every aspect of IT upon which we rely today – every billion-dollar sub-category of the IT industry – bears the clear stamp of federally supported university-based research. These relatively modest investments have played an essential role in the past, and will play an essential role in the future. CRA’s mission in Washington is to be the voice for the computer researching community and to make sure that Congress and Administration officials, regardless of party, are aware of the benefits of this publicly funded research.
Relevant Documents
- CRA Support for the National Quantum Initiative (H.R.6227)
Letter of Support for the National Quantum Initiative - CRA Endorsement of S. 3084 - the American Innovation and Competitiveness Act of 2016 - June 2016
CRA's Endorsement of the Senate American Innovation and Competitiveness Act (S. 3084), including the Senate version of a NITRD Reauthorization bill. - CRA Endorsement NITRD Modernization Act of 2016 - May 2016
CRA's endorsement letter to the House Science, Space, and Technology Committee for the Networking and Information Technology Research and Development Modernization Act of 2016
Relevant Blog Posts
- FY25 Appropriations Update: Senate Marks for NSF, NIST, NASA Released; Contains Increase for NSF, other Agencies, and Expands Funds for Chips Act Implementation
Analysis of the Fiscal Year 2025 Senate Appropriations Committee’s Commerce, Justice, Science legislation. - OSTP Releases Research Security Memo to Research Agencies; Begins Implementation Timeline
OSTP released their long-expected memo on "Guidelines for Research Security Programs at Covered Institutions;" begins implementation timeline for research security programs. - FY25 Appropriations Update: House Appropriators Recommend Flat Funding the Office of Science but Give a Healthy Increase to ASCR
Analysis of the Fiscal Year 2025 House Appropriations Committee's Energy & Water legislation, which covers Department of Energy programs. - FY25 Appropriations Update: House Appropriators Provide Modest Increases for Research at NSF, NIST, and NASA; Other Areas Receive Significant Cuts
Analysis of the Fiscal Year 2025 House Appropriations Committee's Commerce, Justice, Science legislation. - FY25 Appropriations Update: The House Proposes Another Set of Difficult Funding Cuts for the Defense Research Accounts
Analysis of the Fiscal Year 2025 House Appropriations Committee's Defense Legislation. - Bipartisan Group of Senators Release Legislative Roadmap Report on Artificial Intelligence Policy
A bipartisan group of Senators released a report outlining policy and legislative recommendations on how the Senate should approach regulating artificial intelligence. - FY24 Budget Update: Second Part of Federal Budget Passed into Law; Defense Basic Research Hit with Significant Cut
Analysis for the final budgets for the Defense S&T accounts and NIH for the Fiscal Year 2024 Budget. - NSF FY2025 Request: NSF Gets Another Good Budget Request but With Some Qualifications and Unknowns
First in a series of posts covering the Biden Administration's FY25 agency budget requests that are important to the computing research community. First up: the National Science Foundation. - President Biden Releases High Level Budget Overview for Fiscal Year 2025; NSF Receives 12% Increase but with an Asterisk
The Biden Administration released a high-level overview of their $7.3 trillion budget request for Fiscal Year 2025 (FY25). - CRA Statement Expressing Serious Concerns About Fiscal Year 2024 Funding Levels at the National Science Foundation and Other Key Federal Research Agencies
CRA Statement Expressing Serious Concerns About Fiscal Year 2024 Funding Levels at the National Science Foundation and Other Key Federal Research Agencies.
Defense R&D
Many of the technologies that have enabled our current economic prosperity and increased our national security have their roots in university research supported by DARPA. The Internet, graphical user interfaces, and global positioning systems are all the result of long-term, cutting edge, university based research, supported decades ago by DARPA. The CS community still receives a significant amount of funding from defense related sources and it is vital that the community continue to the how the money is spent and in which directions the research is being taken.
Relevant Documents
- CNSR Statement on FY2016 SAC-D Bill
Coalition for the National Security Research (CNSR) statement on the Fiscal Year 2016 Senate Appropriations Committee Defense Bill.
Relevant Blog Posts
- White House Releases National Security Memorandum on Artificial Intelligence
The Biden Administration released a National Security Memo on Artificial Intelligence. - FY25 Appropriations Update: Senate Appropriators Call for Cuts and Flat Funding for the Defense Research Accounts
Analysis of the Senate Appropriations Committee's Fiscal Year 2025 Defense legislation, which covers Department of Defense research programs. - FY25 Appropriations Update: The House Proposes Another Set of Difficult Funding Cuts for the Defense Research Accounts
Analysis of the Fiscal Year 2025 House Appropriations Committee's Defense Legislation. - Department of Defense FY 2025 Request: Another Brutal Budget Request for the Defense Research Accounts
In our continuing series following the Biden Administration’s Fiscal Year 2025 budget request, we turn to the Department of Defense. - FY24 Budget Update: Second Part of Federal Budget Passed into Law; Defense Basic Research Hit with Significant Cut
Analysis for the final budgets for the Defense S&T accounts and NIH for the Fiscal Year 2024 Budget. - Biden Administration Releases Executive Order on Artificial Intelligence
The Biden administration released an executive order on artificial intelligence on October 30th, setting new privacy, anti-discrimination, and safety standards for AI throughout the executive branch, while also seeking to accelerate innovation and bolster the AI workforce. - House Defense Policy Legislation Contains Proposed Onerous Reporting Requirements for Scientists Performing Defense Research
An onerous amendment on research security was included in the House's version of the 2023 National Defense Authorization Act.
CS Education & IT Workforce
Having a highly skilled IT workforce is crucial to America’s economic future, to ensuring our national security, and to maintain our leadership in the world research and development community. In order to assess that workforce, it is crucial that we understand the number of science and engineering degrees granted to American students annually. The flagship publication of CRA is the annual Taulbee Survey, which tracks information on the enrollment, production, and employment of Ph.D.s in computer science and computer engineering and in providing salary and demographic data for CS and CE faculty in North America. CRA takes an active role in disseminating the information collected in the Taulbee Survey to policy makers and other decision makers in Washington. As well, CRA is an active voice for Computer Science education, working with other organizations, both inside and outside the Computer Science community, in order to better prepare Americans for life in a IT-integrated world.
Relevant Documents
- STEM ED Coalition Letter on ESEA - Nov 2015
STEM Education Coalition letter on the 2015 Elementary & Secondary Education Act (ESEA) conference bill. - ESEA Conference Letter - Sept 2015
Informal STEM coalition letter on 2015 Elementary & Secondary Education Act (ESEA) conference bill, led by Patti Curtis at Museum of Science - Code.org ESEA Letter - Oct 2015
Coalition of computing organizations advocating for reauthorization of the 2015 version of the Elementary & Secondary Education Act (ESEA).
Relevant Blog Posts
- NSF FY2023 Request: Again, President Biden Calls for a Strong Vision for NSF’s Future Backed Up with a Robust Funding Increase
First in a series of posts on the assorted FY23 agency budget requests that are important to the computing research community. First up: the National Science Foundation. As with last year’s budget request, the Biden Administration is advocating a strong vision for NSF, assigning the agency a leading role in many of the Administration’s science priorities, and backing it up with a generous budget increase. - NSF Announces the Establishment of New TIP Directorate to “ensure the U.S. will be a global leader in science, engineering and technology for generations to come”
The Director of the National Science Foundation, Dr. Sethuraman Panchanathan, formally announced the establishment of the Directorate for Technology, Innovation, and Partnerships, or TIP. - Biden Administration Announces Immigration Actions to Attract STEM Talent
The Biden Administration announced several new immigration actions they are taking to attract STEM talent and strengthen the nation's competitiveness. The actions are being taken by both the State Department and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and are designed to ease the pathway for foreign students studying in the US to stay and work in the country once their studies have finished.
Cybersecurity R&D
Information technology systems underpin key industries such as telecommunications and financial services, and also play a vital role in the smooth functioning of critical infrastructure and services, such as transportation systems, the electric power grid, and emergency response capabilities. As computer scientists, CRA is concerned how the Federal government approaches the cybersecurity needs of the country and must always be vigilant that the issue is handled with thought and care. We are particularly concerned the research funds at the relevant Executive Branch agencies, such as the National Science Foundation (NSF), Department of Defense (DOD), Department of Homeland Security (DHS), are adequate to meet the ever-changing needs of this fast-moving field.
Relevant Blog Posts
- AAU Announces New Tool to Highlight Cybersecurity Research at Universities
The Association of American Universities (AAU) announced a new tool for highlighting cybersecurity research and breakthroughs occurring at their member institutions. - New Report Identifies Fundamental Research Needs for Advancing Internet of Things & Cutting-Edge Innovations
A new report, titled, "Rebooting the IT Revolution: A Call to Action," produced by the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) and the Semiconductor Research Corporation (SRC), calls for, "a targeted and coordinated government initiative similar to that which sparked the semiconductor revolution fifty years ago." - Sustained investment in research is needed to combat cyber threats, CISE AD tells Congress
On Tuesday January 27th, the Research and Technology Subcommittee of the House Science, Space, & Technology Committee held it’s first hearing of the 114th Congress. The topic was expanding cyber threats and cybersecurity, and the subcommittee heard from experts from both the private sector and government agencies. Assistant Director of CISE, Jim Kurose, testifying for […]
Internet of Things
Computing technology is rapidly entering another disruptive phase; namely, the Internet of Things. In the same way that the Internet revolutionized access to ideas and information, advances in networked sensing and hardware has revolutionized the way computers can observe and interact with the physical world. Sensing and sensor information processing will have a profound impact. Coupling these systems with advances in machine learning brings dramatic new capabilities including the ability to capture and process tremendous amounts of data, predict behaviors, activities, and the future and manipulate the physical world in response. Physical interaction with “smart systems” will become a common way to manipulate the world around us. Applications of IoT include creating Smart Cities and Smart Homes, in which existing “dumb” infrastructure like roads and buildings becomes intelligent, greatly increasing efficiency and productivity. IoT will transform health care, providing improved, pervasive, and cost-effective health care to millions, including our increasing population of the elderly. This is an area the U.S. cannot afford to cede leadership, and our leadership in this area is not assured. Competition from Asia and the European Union is significant with advances in Smart Cities and Smart Homes outpacing the U.S. The Federal government must be proactive in driving the necessary research, standards, and public/private partnerships to ensure that the greatest benefit is reached with the least negative consequences. Efforts like the Smart Cities and Connected Communities framework developed by NITRD and the recently announced NSF/Intel partnership to secure the IoT should be supported and buttressed where possible.
Relevant Documents
- Letter Detailing CRA's Concerns with the DIGIT Act (S. 2067) - March 2016
A letter to the sponsors of S. 2067, the Developing Innovation in Government and the Internet of Things (DIGIT) Act. - CRA's Endorsement of the the DIGIT Act (Developing Innovation in Government and the Internet of Things) - April 2016
An endorsement letter from CRA sent to the sponsors of the DIGIT Act (S. 2067) - CRA Internet of Things Policy Document
CRA document outlining computing research space and possible policy goals at the federal level for the "Internet of Things."
Relevant Blog Posts
- Computing Researchers Make the Case for Intelligent Infrastructure at Congressional Briefing
On a day when President Donald J. Trump is expected to use his State of the Union address to unveil his administration’s plans for nationwide infrastructure investment, a panel representing computing researchers in academia and industry told a group of congressional staffers and other stakeholders that while those infrastructure needs are critical, it would be […] - NSF Funded IoT Security Research Excites at the 2017 CNSF Exhibition
On May 16th, the Coalition for National Science Funding (CNSF), an alliance of over 140 professional organizations, universities, and businesses, held their 23rd Annual Capitol Hill Exhibition. CNSF supports the goal of increasing the federal investment in the National Science Foundation’s research and education programs, and the exhibition itself is a great way to show members of Congress and their staff what research the American people have funded. - New Report Identifies Fundamental Research Needs for Advancing Internet of Things & Cutting-Edge Innovations
A new report, titled, "Rebooting the IT Revolution: A Call to Action," produced by the Semiconductor Industry Association (SIA) and the Semiconductor Research Corporation (SRC), calls for, "a targeted and coordinated government initiative similar to that which sparked the semiconductor revolution fifty years ago."
Impediments to Research
Impediments to CS research are many. Visa issues and other immigration problems; deemed export restrictions; federal requirements on public access to research data (Open Data) and journal publications (Open Access); and legislation targeting key science funding agencies, such as the National Science Foundation, are all examples of dangers to research that have come about in Washington. While many of these are unintended, or are wrapped up in larger issues outside the CS community’s expertise, it is still important to monitor what is happening and try to bring attention to bear whenever possible.
Relevant Documents
- CRA Statement in Response to White House Exec Order on Visas
CRA's response to an Executive Order suspending new visas for foreign nationals of seven countries for at least 90 days. CRA expresses concern that the suspension could create hardships for students and researchers already contributing to the US science enterprise and could discourage talented foreign nationals from coming to the US in the future. - Joint Computing Societies Letter on Information Diffusion Research at Indiana University - November 2014
Letter from five leading computing societies and associations, sent to the Chairman and Ranking Member of the House Science Committee, expressing their concern over mischaracterizations of research on information diffusion in online social networks at Indiana University.
Relevant Blog Posts
- OSTP Releases Research Security Memo to Research Agencies; Begins Implementation Timeline
OSTP released their long-expected memo on "Guidelines for Research Security Programs at Covered Institutions;" begins implementation timeline for research security programs. - NSF Announces New TRUST Research Security Risk Management Framework
The National Science Foundation announced their new TRUST Research Security Risk Management Framework. - CRA Statement Expressing Serious Concerns About Fiscal Year 2024 Funding Levels at the National Science Foundation and Other Key Federal Research Agencies
CRA Statement Expressing Serious Concerns About Fiscal Year 2024 Funding Levels at the National Science Foundation and Other Key Federal Research Agencies. - House Defense Policy Legislation Contains Proposed Onerous Reporting Requirements for Scientists Performing Defense Research
An onerous amendment on research security was included in the House's version of the 2023 National Defense Authorization Act. - NSF Releases Guidelines for Research Security Analytics Practices
The National Science Foundation released their long-anticipated guidelines covering their internal guidance for research security data-related practices. - The Debt Limit Deal and How it Could Impact Research Funding
Breakdown of the impacts on science research of the debt limit deal struck by President Biden and Speaker McCarthy. - Guest Post: Proposed House Budget Would Reduce Federal R&D By An Estimated $442 Billion or 19% Over 10 Years
Guest post by Matt Hourihan at FAS on the potential impacts of discretionary budgetary caps on federal R&D.